Some possible reasons why demand is declining


Attending the AEMO’s feedback session on their planning documents yesterday, I was reminded that I had meant to follow-on my discussion about how demand is changing across the NEM with some of the possible reasons that we’ve either deduced for ourselves, or have had suggested** by a number of our clients.

** Suggestions made by clients and others have been included below, where possible.  Any mistakes in these explanations are entirely ours!

In no particular order, the following are some of the possible reasons.

1)  Factors contributing to demand growth levelling off, and maybe declining

It’s probable that most (if not all) of the following factors have been combining since 2006 to change the pattern of demand in the NEM (+ probably other factors we have not listed here, or thought of).

1a)  Demand might be being offset by…

i. Solar PV

The high level of support for small-scale solar PV installations across the country (through deemed multipliers on RECs in the SRES) and state-based feed-in tariff has reportedly seen an explosion in the installation of solar PV across the country.

It is our understanding that no-one really has a full picture of what is installed across the country:

1)  It was reported here in the Fairfax press that 1,100MW had been installed across the country;

2)  We heard yesterday that Energex has 300MW currently installed in their distribution area alone – amounting to “one in fifteen homes” as reported here.  I can recall hearing something like 500MW in Sydney, as well.

If anyone can point us at more detailed (and/or accurate) information, we’d be very curious to know?

ii.  Other embedded generation

At a larger scale, we’re also seeing some movement in terms of cogeneration and other embedded generation projects in the commercial and industrial space.  Some examples include:

1)  Origin (through their Cogent Energy subsidiary) and their commercial project at 101 Miller St in North Sydney, which they talk about here.

2)  Earlier this year, AGL announced (here) their partnership with Qenos in the installation of a sizeable cogeneration project at the Qenos site in Victoria – to follow on from other cogeneration projects at Coopers Brewery, Melbourne Water and elsewhere.

3)  Several years ago, Sucrogen upgraded its Pioneer sugar mill to become a sizeable cogeneration plant, and the other sugar mill operators are looking to complete similar projects.

1b)  Demand might be being reduced by…

i. Hang-over from the GFC

When the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) first hit, we did some preliminary analysis here.

Though the effect of the GFC was much lower, and less persistent, than in some other parts of the world, it has certainly had some effect.  It would not be possible to ascertain precisely how much.

ii. Two-speed economy

It has been commonly reported that Australia might be blessed (or cursed) with a two-speed economy.

If this is the case, and the majority of the benefits of the mining and commodities boom is being seen in Western Australia (not connected to the NEM) and Queensland (including some parts not connected to the NEM), it is probable that the results seen in terms of changing demand shapes would be attributable (at least in part) to this.

Of particular interest, in terms of electricity demand, is the reported “hollowing out of Australia’s manufacturing base” – and the disproportionate effect that might be seen in terms of electricity demand, as a result.

iii. Energy Efficiency Measures at Home

Driven by a combination of higher prices, raised environmental consciousness (through Earth Hour and other initiatives) and government initiatives, it’s commonly acknowledged that there has been progress towards greater energy efficiency in our homes.

A number of measures will have contributed to this, including:

1)  Higher efficiency lighting.  Some back-of-the-envelope calculations shows that this benefit, in terms of ongoing reduction in demand, might be substantial.

2)  Higher efficiency appliances, such as more efficient air-conditioning and and large-screen TVs – along with better standards for standby power.

3)  The much maligned federal ceiling insulation scheme would be contributing to reduced demand for electricity across much of the year.  A more difficult question would be to ascertain by how much.

4)  Additionally, we’ve started to see reports (such as in “McMansions losing their allure” on 22nd August in the AFR) that we might have collectively turned the corner in terms of demanding ever-increasing floor areas in new housing stock, with a decline in average floor area apparently seen since 2009.

iv. Energy Efficiency Measures at Work

Various State and Federal government initiatives (such as EEO and NGERS) would also be having some impact on the changing pattern of demand.

v. Price sensitivity of demand

I previously started a discussion about how rising prices for electricity were a major concern for large industrial energy users.  This is the type of analysis that is never really finished…

Undoubtedly the recent increases in prices will have had some effect of moderating consumption – both at work and at home.

———

Can you see other possible contributing factors?  If so please either:
1) Give us a call +61 (0)7 3368 4064 and let us know; or
2) Post them as comments below.

2)  Possible implications of this

We haven’t given this a whole load of thought, but it does appear to be very significant to the market and the electricity supply industry as a whole, for a number of reasons – including:

(a)  Numerous people have spoken about how the declining load factor in the NEM (and elsewhere around the world) makes for a more expensive electricity supply system (in capital terms) and also an accelerating average cost (per MWh).

(b)  This points to a greater need for measures such as Demand Side Response to mitigate these market-wide costs.

(c)  At a more fundamental level – there may be a paradigm shift under way, and one that might accelerate under a “smart-grid” enabled but carbon-constrained world.  If this is the case, then there will be a greater level of uncertainty about what might unfold in the future.  This means that previous “rules of thumb” might no longer hold true, and that there may be cost implications about this level of uncertainty.

(d)  Additionally, it also means that there are a greater range of stakeholders who have a significant impact on where demand will head for the future.

Key to considering possible implications is to understand whether this is a transient occurrence (such as if it is driven by a depressed economy in some sectors, or by retrofitting existing stock with insulation and changed light-bulbs etc…) or whether it is a more fundamental change (such as if driven by new technology).

When we have a bit more time, we’ll continue to ponder this situation – and will post some analysis of each of the factors, when we are able.

We’d welcome comments below – or on the phone +61 (0)7 3368 4064

About the Author

Paul McArdle
One of three founders of Global-Roam back in 2000, Paul has been CEO of the company since that time. As an author on WattClarity, Paul's focus has been to help make the electricity market more understandable.

6 Comments on "Some possible reasons why demand is declining"

  1. Good morning

    Additional (albeit minor) reasons reducing electricity demand (apologies for the Queensland bias):
    – Increased Demand Side Management e.g. Energex’s Cool Change Trial – A 13 per cent reduction in peak energy demand was achieved on the hottest day of the 2009/2010 summer (www.energex.com.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0015/32352/Cool-Change-Cool-Change-Newsletter-November-2010-with-form-number.pdf)
    – Household types and composition. Increasing densification of capital city populations is changing the historic relationship between population growth and electricity demand growth. IPART’s survey of residential energy demand illustrates the difference between house and unit electricity use by number of residents, as well as the impact of adults (>15 years old) versus children.
    – Industrial strucure and growth. Low growth in energy intensive industries (e.g. manufacturing) and high growth in service industries (typically low energy intensity) has reduced business electricity demand growth.
    – Resdiential high-draw devices. There has been sizeable growth in high-draw devices (primarily air conditioners) over the past 15 years, but the market is now close to saturation point in some categories (what is stopping the 20% of high-income households that don’t have an air conditioner from purchasing one?), which coupled with increased efficiency of high-draw devices, would be expected to reduce growth in electricity demand from these devices (closer to the growth in new dwellings).

    Evan

    • Hi Evan

      Thanks for the thoughts – and apologies for the delay in responding.

      I am curious to delve further into the detail, in order to understand the significance of these factors, and others people have noted. When time permits, I’ll be doing this with the database we’ve accumulated of sub-regional demand histories across the NEM – which should allow the benefit of (to some extent at least) looking at the effect in different sectors of the economy, and with respect to different weather patterns, etc….

      Regards

      Paul

  2. Good day,

    If we are referring to forecast maximum seasonal demands, it could an overly optimistic forward projection influence mainly by outlandish economic forecast, the need for capx investment into aging network, influx of migrants, the weather, etc, etc.

    Notice that post GFC period, the economy did not shrink but grow at a slower pace, which means that the behaviour on energy utilisation has changed. This is inline with what Paul has mentioned on energy efficiency measures and retail price of electricity. However not forgetting that in recently 1-3 years, the weather is cooler not any warmer (especially in Queensland for where i am from).

    • Thanks Ken

      Appreciate your points.

      The numbers I have looked at, to date, have been NEM-wide. To some extent this means that regional patterns (e.g. cooler summers in recent years in QLD) have their effects masked.

      Regards

      Paul

  3. There is another rather prosiac reason for a weak energy demand in 2010/11: the natural disasters over the summer, most particularly the Brisbane River flood which supressed Qld demand for over a week. It would be possible to estimate this effect.

    On “embedded generation” a few points. Of course, what NEM commentators colloquially describe as “demand” is a misnomer, it is actually a measure of generation, and then only a subset of that-that which is easily measurable. And the “demand” excludes some generators, but includes losses in generating, transmitting and distributing electricity, which all change in turn with the pattern of dispatch!

    The easily measured generation is all “scheduled” and “semi-scheduled” generation. This is most generators with connection point capacity>30MW and some larger windfarms built prior to 2010. AEMO publishes the large non-scheduled wind generation separately, so that “demand” can be recovered, but as you correctly point out there are still many other non-scheduled generators for which AEMO has no data, such as PV’s and co-generators below 30MW.

    On the terminology, the rules define “embedded generation” as any distribution connected generation (which includes the 400MW Tallawarra!)-so I think what you mean is “non-scheduled”. We have lots of embedded scheduled generation, such as Tallawarra.

    On attempting to estimate the trend of demand for the future, the AEMO CEO presented on this matter at the ESOO launch: http://www.aemo.com.au/corporate/0007-0003.pptx

    • Thanks, Ben (once again) for contributing

      The ESI is full of commodities that are difficult to measure in actuality!

      As noted to Evan (above) I am keen to delve more into the history of zonal data we have in order to at least be able to identify the extent to which the trend observed on a NEM-wide basis (with the approximation of real demand) is similar across the 26 zones for which we have data NEM-wide.

      With so many data sets to analyse, it should be able to provide some insight into the extent to which various factors are at work – e.g. residential -vs- industrial -vs- commercial, north -vs- south, etc…

      In terms of estimating demand for the future, I would also like to have time to complete this type of retrospective on forecasts. Perhaps AEMO might include this in the data it releases in 2012?

      Regards

      Paul

41 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Has the demand pattern been different on a regional basis? | WattClarity
  2. Entries in our competition for summer 2011-12 | WattClarity
  3. Summer continues, but demand has not (yet?) arrived | WattClarity
  4. Hot in VIC and SA – but demand not climbing past the green zone | WattClarity
  5. Hydro generation increases with La Nina | WattClarity
  6. Recapping NEM-Wide demand (or the lack thereof) over summer | WattClarity
  7. 3 Questions we’ve been asked, following the introduction of the Carbon Tax | WattClarity
  8. AFR says “Emissions have fallen"! Here’s some more data… | WattClarity
  9. Trends in power station output by fuel type | WattClarity
  10. Liquidity of futures trading in Australia’s National Electricity Market | WattClarity
  11. Prices soar as the south-east sizzles – with summer arriving early | WattClarity
  12. A stinker today in southern Queensland, leading to high demand and prices on the tipping point | WattClarity
  13. To what extent is Wind reducing spot prices in South Australia? | WattClarity
  14. Celebrate a summer Christmas with us–with your own new Beefmaster Premium 6 BBQ! | WattClarity
  15. A more detailed look at how demand has trended over 15 summers in the NEM | WattClarity
  16. How has Demand Diversity changed, over 15 summers? | WattClarity
  17. Some factors that contributed to the remarkable volatility in Queensland over the weekend | WattClarity
  18. Recapping NEM-wide demand for summer 2012-13 | WattClarity
  19. Highest electricity demand for Victoria in four years last Tuesday (12th March) – and 400MW of DSR operates | WattClarity
  20. Chilly winter evenings show demand has declined for various reasons – not just solar PV | WattClarity
  21. The NEM might support 37% energy supplied from wind – but it would still require at least 21GW of non-wind capacity on standby | WattClarity
  22. Has declining demand claimed its next victim? | WattClarity
  23. Is solar PV providing more opportunity for spot price engineering? | WattClarity
  24. Give your Summer extra Sizzle with our Suggested “Seasons Greetings” Submission (and win your new Premium Beefmaster 6 Burner BBQ on Cart with Side Burner) | WattClarity
  25. Heatwave threatens to melt Victorian all-time electricity demand record today – with Reserve Trader getting a run | WattClarity
  26. Demand Response also helps Victoria and South Australia beat the heat | WattClarity
  27. One left-of-field option for generator rationalisation | WattClarity
  28. A few thoughts on the RET Review process | WattClarity
  29. Behind all the buzz about Solar PV… | WattClarity
  30. Winter evening price spike – like yesteryear (not quite) | WattClarity
  31. Can you sizzle like the pros – by calculating one of these metrics for summer in the NEM? | WattClarity
  32. Will Queensland defy the trend of declining demand? | WattClarity
  33. Analysing trends in VIC electricity demand | WattClarity
  34. If your horse did not come in today – here’s a better chance to win a BBQ (and possibly* a bottle of Grange) | WattClarity
  35. Highest electricity demand in NSW so far this summer seen today | WattClarity
  36. What’s going on with Victorian electricity demand? | WattClarity
  37. [Post 2] Demand climbs and smelter readies to close AGAIN | WattClarity
  38. Another industrial energy user enters Liquidation (in South Australia this time)
  39. Electricity demand stopped declining after 2014 (on a NEM-wide, Annual Average basis)
  40. My first look at the highs, and lows, in Victoria and South Australia on Thursday 24th January 2019 – WattClarity
  41. Some early comments made about the Generator Report Card – WattClarity

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*